5 min read

For all you know: re-released

(Free post) One last trip into the vault for 2026! Many of us have heard the advice to "write what we know", but we can go deeper than that, with some help from Bill Manhire.
For all you know: re-released
Photo by Hans-Peter Gauster / Unsplash

This week's post is one last throwback for the year. I originally published this post in May of 2025 for my paid subscribers, and as it's such a useful topic I thought it would be an excellent candidate to be re-released for everyone else's benefit. I also took the opportunity to make some improvements, so even if you've read the first version you may still find some new gems in this one.


When I wrote about notable writers from Aotearoa New Zealand in an earlier post, I mentioned a piece of writing wisdom from the author Bill Manhire which has stuck with me since the first time I heard it. The person who passed it onto me was one of my lecturers for the Master of Writing that I was studying for in 2020, and I'm very excited to be able to share it with you as well.

The advice in question is a reframing of the old chestnut to "write what you know", which has been irking writers, especially those specialising in sci-fi and fantasy, for god knows how long. Fiction is all about making things up and exploring other people's lives, after all, and speculative fiction couldn't exist at all if we didn't write about things we have never experienced. As a result, many of the writers I've talked to don't think very much of the idea.

Manhire's version of writing what you know, on the other hand, is a two-step process that grasps the goal of fiction-writing much more firmly:

  1. Write what you know, and
  2. Write what you don't know.

Much more sensible already, don't you think? But we can't just leave it at that; let's take a moment to explore what it really means to write what you know, as well as what you don't, and how that plays out in practice.

What you know

When I was in my final year of high school, I remember my class being given a creative writing assignment, along with the standard recommendation to write about things we knew. Now, although I am generally a very laid-back sort of person, I do occasionally develop a contrarian ambitious streak, and this was one of those occasions. I therefore decided that I was going to write deliberately about experiences I had never witnessed in my life, let alone experienced myself, and ended up with a short story that contrasted the perspectives of two grown men in wildly different circumstances envying what they see of the other's love life.

Needless to say, I felt very pleased with myself for having pulled it off (especially when I got top marks for the assignment). However, having recalled this event in light of my newfound understanding, I don't know if I really achieved the coup that I had intended. Had I really successfully refused to write what I knew? Sure, I'd never been a dashing playboy or comfortably middle-aged man like my characters, but, like many people, I could understand the feeling of seeing someone else's life and thinking that looks so good; I wish I could have something like that. And that feeling was what my story was really about, not the totally imagined experiences of being a playboy or a middle-aged man.

So when we think about Manhire's advice and start with writing what we know already, that's the sort of thing we really need to focus on: finding those relatable emotional beats, the undercurrents of lived experience that can be woven into your plots. Even though your characters live very different lives to you, they will still have feelings, traits, and responses that you may be able to connect to or identify with. If you nurture these pieces of understanding, your writing will feel more grounded and relatable to readers, even if the backdrop of the emotional journey contains dragons or spaceships.

Writing what you know also means using topics you're already familiar with to build and shape your story; when Tolkien wrote The Lord of the Rings, he used his expertise in early medieval European cultures as a foundation of his worldbuilding, as well as infusing the story with his wartime experiences. Similarly, his close friend C S Lewis relied on his deep theological knowledge to develop a number of his fictional works, including The Chronicles of Narnia and The Screwtape Letters. For you, useful topics to build your writing on might be drawn from your culture, from travels, or from subjects you have studied or trained in. Using your expertise as a foundation is a great way to make your writing come alive and showcase the little details that really make a story believable.

Looking at it from that perspective, what does it mean for you, personally, to write what you know? For me, it may mean that I write about lived experiences with queerness or living in Aotearoa New Zealand, or from my knowledge of history and Shakespeare characters. Tell me about the things you know in the comments using the button below.

But don't stop here! Remember that this is only step 1 of 2...

What you don't know

Now that you've established the things you do know, it's time to expand into the unfamiliar. This is the point where you need to figure out what all you don't know yet, and then go about filling in those gaps until you have a coherent piece of work. There are a couple of categories of unknown knowledge you might be faced with:

  • Things you don't know, but others do: this is the stuff you need to do research on. You may need to learn more about a historical or cultural context related to your story, or about specialist topics that your characters know more about than you do.
  • Things nobody knows: these are the details you need to come up with yourself, including characters' appearances and development, worldbuilding, and other fictional story-specific information.

So, for example, when I chose to write a play based on late-17th-century stage comedy, I needed to find out more about that genre and style of theatre. I grabbed some examples of plays from the period to study, and since I was approaching this project academically for my Master's I also read through some relevant secondary resources discussing the historical period and the themes I wanted to explore. For another project (a detective series I've started writing), I have a whole set of documents set up where I can record all the random little details I come up with, from locations and names to notes on my protagonists' characterisation.

Sometimes, coming up with brand new, fictional details also requires you to build on some relevant specialised knowledge as well. Worldbuilding, for instance, is very specific to a book or series, but developing a functional, believable world will likely necessitate research on real civilisations, whether current or historical. You might also need to talk to people from particular cultures or social groups to make sure that you're representing those cultures or groups appropriately as you develop characters with the same background.

When you move beyond writing what you know into writing what you don't know, you will inevitably need to spend more time on making sure the piece makes sense and remains consistent. Doing so will also help you to better understand the new ideas and information you're implementing. This two-step process brings the things you don't know into the realm of the things you do and, whether you're writing about the familiar or the fantastic, you still need to know it in your head before you can write it down for other people.

When we really get down to brass tacks, Manhire's advice doesn't really contradict the tired old maxim of writing what we know. What it does do, though, is clarify the saying's practical application. We start with the things we know now, then move onto the stuff we don't know yet, making the unknown known in the process. Hopefully this reframing is as much of a lightbulb moment for you as it was for me!